Public Health Reflection on Care

Public Health Reflection on C arTitle Reflect upon an incident which occurred during your clinical placement as a scholar Public Health Nurse. The chosen incident is one where you met an elderly client with a leg ulceration who was not complying with the sermon prescribed from hospital.This essay is a reflective consideration of a case that had been encountered in clinical practice. For the purposes of illustrative intervention, I shall use the Gibbs model of demonstration as a necessitate. (Gibbs, G 1988)verbal description describe in c.400 words the experience. Client fell at home and fractured lower ankle. He neglected this and developed ulcer. He attended GP and holy 2 gos of antibiotics referred to leg ulcer clinic in local hospital diagnosis was ulcer with mixed arterial / venous disease.The client concerned will be anonymised and referred to as Mr.S in accordance with the NMC guidelines (NMC 2004). Mr.S is a 68 yr old man who lives alone having been widowed for 12 year s. He is normally self feel for nevertheless has been getting progressively more frail as time goes by. He fell at home and fractured his lower tibia. There was a hunch that he has been drinking rather more than might be considered peachy for him and it is possible that this fall was after a b prohibited of drinking. (Nicol M et al. 2004).Being slackly very stoical, he initially ignored this but was forced to pick upk medical advice when the pain got too great. The fracture was treated with a plaster cylinder after reduction of the fracture but he subsequently developed a leg ulcer from direct pressure and friction from the cylinder which eventually attained a size of about 10 15 cms across and, despite being referred to the leg ulcer clinic and having regular visits from the community nurse who employ Aquacell AG , it ref employ to heal. (Harding K G et al. 2002)It was subsequently discovered that after the nurses had been to clean and dress the leg, Mr.S would take the d ressings off and put iodine onto the hurt which produced a pronounced allergic reaction. When challenged about this he said that he didnt hold with these newfangled ideas and that he wanted to use a remedy that his grandmother had used with great success when she had developed a leg ulcer. Initially there was an impasse with the nurses wanting to use the dressings that had been prescribed by the hospital and Mr.S, although allowing them to be out on, would promptly disturb them and put the iodine directly onto the wound. The community nurses were asked to persist with the dressing regime and after a few weeks it became clear that the leg ulcer was qualification no progress at all. It was not healing, it was permanently infected and persistently sore with inflamed and macerated wound edges. (Donnelly A et al. 2000).There was considerable discussion in the primary healthcare team relating to Mr.Ss right to autonomy (Seedhouse D 1998) and whether it was right or not to continue to co mmit large amounts of resources to a clinical incident that was not only not healing but was rattling being actively undermined and made worse by the patient. (Thomas J E et al. 1990). To an extent, it is not ethical to insist on, or to impose a interference which the patient is (by word or action) objecting to. It is difficult to justify a course of sanative action, which may have the strongest of severalize bases, if the patient does not want it. (Hunt T 1994)The spatial relation was compounded by the fact that Mr.S was not an easy patient to apportion with as, since his wife died, he had become progressively more reclusive and he was all the way uneasy with other people coming into his house. The current course of treatment was clearly not successful and therefore a completely different approach needed to be tried.Feelings how did client/you/others feel in this situation? How did you whap this? The student was annoyed that the client was not complying with treatment and she knew the treatment he was applying was outdated and potentially harmful. savant is accountable to An Bord Altranais for their practice and must refer to evidence based practice. Student observed how the treatment applied by client had its place in the past and PHN made family aware that new dressings have argent content which has greatly improved results. Empowerment and advocacy were adopted.I found my looks ran through an evolution of emotions and that the initial set of feelings were of annoyance, frustration and irritation that Mr.S could not see that the healthcare professionals were trying to help him. I initially saw him as a rude and aggressive gentleman who clearly did not want snag from the nurses and was content to live in comparative squalor. His persistence of the use of the iodine seemed to me to be mainly due to sheer perversity rather than any wise logical thinking. (Osterberg L et al. 2005)I know that my original exchanges with him were very terse and aggre ssive, as I could not understand why he was persisting in use something which had no substantive evidence base and was clearly making the situation worse. My feelings changed to being less overtly annoyed as I came to realise that Mr.S was actually trying to use something that he had seen his grandmother use to heal her own leg ulcer and that there was a period of reason beneath his obstinacy.My learn took a different view and explained that empowerment and knowledge (Howe J et al. 2003) was the way to achieve success with Mr.S and I watched as she firstly gained his confidence and then explained the reasoning behind the new Aquacell AG, she in any case explained that the iodine, far from helping healing was, in his particular case, preventing the leg ulcer from healing and that his situation was quite different from the situation of his grandmothers ulcer. (Miller, A. 1995). After about three sessions, it was noted that Mr.S had stopped interfering with the dressings and that the iodine was no longer being applied. As a result, the wound started to heal. As soon as he saw this, Mr.S became much more content to allow the nurses to continue with their work and actually became al closely welcoming. (Faden, R R et al. 1986). At this stage, I found that my feelings changed to actually liking Mr.S and looking forward to each meeting. I also developed a great deal of compliancy for my mentor and the other important realisation was a feeling of annoyance towards myself at my own initial inability to realise the motivation behind Mr.Ss actions. (Schon, D. 1997)Evaluation what was good and bad about the situation? Mentor was able to develop relationship of trust with client.The bad elements of the situation was that the concept of empowerment and education (Howe J et al. 2003), was not embraced earlier in the treatment programme and that each treatment application was simply met by the acceptance that Mr.S was interfering with the dressings. There was the super numerary possibility that Mr.S was drinking more than was good for him and this element of the situation was overlooked with the prime focus being on the leg ulcer rather than making a holistic assessment of the whole situation. Equally bad was my inexperience-based lack of insight into the situation.On the good side, the fact that the mentor was able to stand indorse from the situation and make a dispassionate and empathetic assessment of the situation, construct an appropriate solicitudes plan and then persuade Mr.S to comply with it to achieve a good clinical outcome, was a very positive step and a testament to the clinical experience of the mentor.Analysis what sense can you make of the situation? what knowledge did or should have informed you? how does this connect with previous experiences? Reflection is necessary to enlighten a clinical situation. Element of compromise needed. Client centred approach required. Student PHN had experience of working as Community General Nurse . She found observing how the mentor dealt with the situation very enlightening. Discussion with clients family was beneficial.Analysis of the situation shows the potential disjuncture between the pursuit of evidence based medicine and the practical difficulties in actually applying it. It is all very well knowing that Aquacell AG releases ionic coin into the wound in a delayed and controlled release manner as the wound exudate is absorbed, thereby releasing more silver in the most contaminated wounds. ( derby P G, 2003).The fact that the dressing formulation itself is thought to protect the periwound skin and thereby aid in granulation formation is of supposed importance. In cases of leg ulceration, the fact that the dressing conforms easily to the surface of the wound helps with occlusion and thereby maintains a moist healing environment (Jude E B et al. 2007) is clearly a substantial contribution to the evidence base in this area. The fact that dressing exerts a demonstrable antimicrobial activity for up to 7 days reduces the need for frequent dressing changes and therefore frequent wound disturbance (Jude E B et al. 2007) is of practical and clinical importance, but none of these factors are of any use at all if the patient does not understand or is willing to comply with the clinical therapeutic regime.In essence, this case illustrates the disconnect between the knowledge that is assimilated in an isolated academic situation and the knowledge that is derived from experience in clinical situations. (Van Manen, M. 2007). It was my reflection on the situation that allowed me to appreciate the on-key value of my mentors experience and handling of the situation which was the critical factor in persuading Mr.S to understand both his predicament and the rationale behind the treatment that was being offered and this was the key to his eventual understanding and compliance. (Marinker M. 1997). It was clear that simply persisting with the situation was not goin g to achieve the desired effect and that a degree of compromise was needed. That compromise was achieved by viewing the situation from the patients viewpoint and then tailoring the clinical approach to an empathetic understanding of that perspective. In other words a client centred approach. (Platt, F W et al. 1999).The point about Mr.Ss drinking was no longer overlooked and discussions with his extended family substantiate the clinical suspicion. Pressure was exerted by the family to reduce the opportunities for his drinking and they increased the degree of social interaction (reduced his social isolation) which also had a beneficial effect (Wilkerson, S. A et al. 1996)Conclusion how do you now feel about this experience? what else could you have done? has this changed my ways of knowing?I can say with confidence that reflection on this whole episode was a major learning experience for me. Not only did I witness and important lesson in patient management, but I was able to reflect on the evolution of my emotional approach to the situation. It showed me how my initial aggression and annoyance was not only completely misplaced, but that it was also completely counterproductive. As a completion, I have seen just how important it is to stand back from a difficult or deteriorating situation and make a completely dispassionate and holistic assessment of the patient and his clinical situation before trying to construct an appropriate management plan. A further conclusion must be that there is very little merit in simply knowing the evidence base surrounding a particular course of treatment if one lacks the experience or humanity to actually effectively put it into action. (Fawcett J 2005)Action Plan if this arose again, what would you do differently?As I have already mentioned in the conclusion, it is because this episode was a major learning experience for me that I can say with confidence that, if a similar situation arose again, I would deal with it in a comple tely different way to the way which I handled this episode. I would not initially approach Mr.S with a feeling of aggression and annoyance as it proved not only to be counterproductive but it was also a barrier to my standing back and reviewing the situation. If Mr.S was clearly not complying with the treatment I would ask myself (and the patient) what were the reasons why compliance was a problem. Having ascertained the reasons, I would then construct an appropriate treatment or management plan which directly addressed this reason and contained a mechanism for directly confronting it. Empowerment and education have been demonstrated to me as very powerful tools in the quest for patient compliance and concordance. I would actively use these concepts to try to maximise the effectiveness of the treatment and also to enhance the overall patient experience. (Hewison, A. 2004)ReferencesBowler P G, 2003. Progression towards Healing wound infection and the role of an advanced silver-contai ning dressing. Ostomy Wound Management 49 (8) Suppl. 2 5Donnelly A, Alistair M Emslie-Smith, Iain D Gardner, and Andrew D Morris (2000) ABC of arterial and venous disease Vascular complications of diabetes BMJ, Apr 2000 320 1062 1066.Faden, R R, Beauchamp, T L. (1986) A History and Theory of Informed Consent Oxford University Press New York. 1986Fawcett J (2005) Contemporary Nursing Knowledge Analysis and Evaluation of Nursing Models and Theories, 2nd Edition. Boston Davis Co 2005 ISBN 0-8036 1194 3Gibbs, G (1988) Learning by doing A guide to Teaching and Learning methods. EMU Oxford Brookes University, Oxford. 1988Harding K G, Morris H L, Patel G K. (2002) Healing chronic wounds. BMJ 2002 324 160 163Hewison, A. (2004) Management for Nurses and Health Professionals Theory into practice. Blackwell Science Oxford. 2004Howe J, Anderson M (2003) Involving patients in medical education. BMJ, Aug 2003 327 326 328.Hunt T (1994) Ethical issues in Nursing. capital of the Unite d Kingdom Routledge 1994Jude E B, Apelqvist J, Spraul M, Martini J. (2007) Prospective randomised controlled study of Hydrofiber dressing containing ionic silver or calcium alginate dressings in non-ischaemic diabetic foot ulcers. Diabet Med. 2007 24 280 288.Marinker M.(1997) From compliance to concordance achieving shared goals in medicine taking. BMJ 1997 314 747 8.Miller, A. (1995) The Relationship between Nursing Theory and Nursing Practice. ledger of Advanced Nursing 10, 417 424.Nicol M, Carol Bavin, Shelagh Bedford-Turner Patricia Cronin, Karen Rawlings-Anderson (2004) Essential Nursing Skills 2nd ed. Churchill Livingstone, Mosby 2004NMC (2004) Nurse Midwifery Council Code of professional conduct Standards for conduct, performance and Ethics (2004) London Chatto Windus 2004Osterberg L, Blaschke T (2005) Adherence to medication. N Engl J Med353 487 497, 2005Platt, F W Gordon G H (1999) Field Guide to the Difficult Patient Interview 1999 Lippincott Williams and Wilki ns, pp 250 ISBN 0 7817 2044 3 London Macmillian Press 1999Schon, D. (1997) Educating the Reflective Practitioner. Jossey Bass, San Francisco. 1997Seedhouse D (1998) Ethics the heart of health care. London, John Wiley Sons 1998Thomas J E Waulchow W J (1990) Well and Good circumstance Studies in Biomedical ethics. Broadview Press 1990Van Manen, M. (2007) Linking Ways of Knowing with Ways of being Practical. Curriculum Inquiry 6 (3), 205 228.Wilkerson, S. A., Loveland-Cherry, C. J. (1996). Johnsons behavioral system model. In J. J. Fitzpatrick A.L. Whall (Eds.), Conceptual models of nursing Analysis and application (3rd ed., pp. 89-109). Stamford, CT Appleton Lange. 1996